Cain has been so bad that the team had no choice but to bench him but McCutchen hasn't been much worse than most of the regulars so I fully expect Counsell to play him everyday unless he reaches similar levels of ineptness that Cain has shown. An analytically aware team like the Brewers should know that McCutchen hasn't hit righties in years and that Hiura has been pretty good against them but as most managers do Counsell is sticking with the veteran due to him being a star player years ago.