The beauty of baseball. There is no right or wrong answer. Both these pitchers have the stuff that can project to be a high-end rotation arm. With both their small sample sizes, there is know way to decide who will be the better pitcher. Freddy is 22 and has proven to be effectively wild. I wouldn't be surprised for him to go 7 innings and give up 2 hits, or go 2 innings and walk 5. I suppose you can expect that for a 22 y/o with the type of delivery that he has. Freddy seems to have a combo of Fiers deception with Carter Capps/ Jordan Walden push off the rubber. That's a nice combination to have. His last game pitched vs the Dodgers he went 3 innings, no hits, 3BB, and 6Ks in a game where he was thrown into a fire. 3 weeks in between starts and he was dominant. His highest velocity all year was that game at 95.8 mph. With his growth and maturity, I wouldn't be surprised to see him sitting around 93mph and hitting 96-97 when he needs it. This guy oozes with potential, and frankly, he has already showcased the potential. Woodruff is a prototype for an ace. A big-country 6'4" 97+mph fastball with life, knockout slider, and a change up that is coming along (NLCS game 1: see Max Muncy). His career path reminds me a bit of Jimmy Nelson's. Great minor league numbers, decent to start his career, and you're just waiting for his breakout. I really think 2019 is when Woodruff becomes that dependable #2 type pitcher. You have to think his playoff run reaffirmed that he not only belongs in the majors, but he can go pitch for pitch with some of the best the league has to offer. Overall, Woodruff seems more refined and has the stuff that typically you want your pitchers to have. Freddy just seems to have it and he is so young and still developing. Unless the Brewers can get a game-changing player added to their team, I would have no issue keeping these guys on the squad. Heck, I wouldn't be opposed to see Woodruff/Hader tandem in the bullpen. That could cut every game to a 6 inning game.