I like Cain, and hope he does great for us this year. My biggest concern is that he took last year off, and said the only exercise he got was chasing after his kids. Counsell is obviously concerned about the shape he's in, as he put him on a program that kept him out of games for the first week in order to get him in shape and ready for game action. Then, in that first week of training he pulled something in his leg, further delaying his progression. These guys are professional athletes. I have doubts that Cain will be at his elite level this year. I hope I'm wrong, but it looks like he took a year off and got soft, and the Brewers are on the hook to pay him regardless of whether or not he gets back to "playing shape." Meanwhile, Garcia shed 35 pounds and looks like a different person. At this point, I'm thinking that it will be Cain who loses the most playing time out of the trio of Bradley, Cain, and Garcia. Either way, I'm glad we have the extra depth. Yes, this. It isn't bashing Cain, it is being realistic about his age, injury history, and taking a year off. If you were to wager on which of our starting OFers was most likely to not reach their career numbers and/or have an injury prone year, which one would you choose? Cain - Age 35 - 288/348/418 Yeli - Age 29 - 296/381/488 Garcia - Age 29 - 271/324/472 Cain is clearly the wild card because of age and time away. Signing JBJ is probably 50% Cain insurance, 25% 4th OFer (which means starting about 10% of games), 15% Garcia insurance/platoon-mate, 9% Yeli injury insurance, and 1% Yeli performance insurance. Either way it adds up to a good move, IMO. I guess I need to pull a PeavyFury and say I never accused anyone of bashing Cain. I guess the guy that posted after me worded a response that way but I didn't. I was pointing out his injury since someone previously wondered if he had one that affected his performance in 2019, I also felt I was careful to leave room for concerns about age etc.