The Brewers have had the opportunity to pick up many players over the years that have pasts with the team. Other than a few rare exceptions (Gio, Broxton I guess this year) Stearns rarely goes that route. There must have been something that Sogard has done, other than his stats last year, that convinced the Brewers that not only was he a good choice to bring back, but at double the salary that he was making when he epically flamed out in 2018. I'm guessing he took steps to remake his swing, which led to the power increase last year. Apparently the Brewers believe that is sustainable. He did alter his swing to increase his launch angle - that coupled with juiced/HR-happy baseballs both really helped him last season. All the while he remained a steady to above average defensive player capable of playing several positions, most noteably 2B. I get the move and actually don't have a problem with paying $4.5 M for a reliable utility IF with a LH bat that will at worst give you a pretty good AB most plate appearances. What I'm struggling with is his nightmarish 2018 with the Brewers and the fact I was among the most vocal proponents of jettisoning him weeks before he was finally released and kicked down to AAA. Hoping he's at least somewhere in the middle between his terrible 2018 and really solid 2019, which would make the signing just fine for thie 2020 roster. This is where I am too. We can look at his 2019 and wonder if it was a fluke or predict that it's not repeatable (due to previous bias), but he still put up those stats. Based on that performance more than one GM was likely going to give the guy a shot at around the salary he ended up signing for. Perhaps he was slightly overpaid, I would think $3 million would be about right, but if he had 2 or more suitors the extra $1.5 million isn't going to have a restrictive impact on how the remainder of the roster is filled.