I'm not the biggest fan of putting Escobar at 2nd base. To me, that is a waste of his extraordinary defensive talents. And I mean extraordinary. I caught a good amount of Escobar down in spring training and was amazed at how good he is defensively. Many times there'd be a shot up the middle that I'm assuming would be a base hit, but Alcides would get there with relative ease and throw the guy out right on the money. I don't claim to be a scout, but I know a very very talented defensive shortstop when I see one. I don't see too many scouts saying his defense is overrated, either. I could see him being a ?20 run guy at SS. I might be a little hesitant to trade JJ after this year, but I'd probably look to do it after 2009. JJ is a very good player but I don't see him moving off shortstop. A trade could be a win-win for JJ and the Brewers at some point assuming we get a decent haul for him and Escobar can hit his own weight (which wouldn't be too hard). JJ would get to stay at SS and reap the rewards when he hits free agency.