I'm not going to get into the whole Kotsay sucks thing, though personally, I'm not a huge fan. If Morgan is back and healthy, that SHOULD push Kotsay to the 5th outfield spot. At that point, to me, it becomes who would be more valuable as a PH/Spot Starter at 1B or RF (assuming Branyan can play RF). In my opinion, it's not even close. Branyan will likely have a lower BA and probably worse defense. However, I'd guess their OBP would be similar, as Branyan does walk a ton. He also DOES possess power that Kotsay has pretty much never had. We have virtually nobody on our bench that I would want to send up if we could really use a HR to tie a game and Branyan would definitely supply that. Ideally, this player would very rarely start (assuming Morgan is healthy) and if we're talking just a bench role, I just don't see how Branyan wouldn't be better than Kotsay, even with his apparent decline.