Until Villar really starts hitting again, I can't see him at the top. For the short term, I like Brinson leading off and Sogard batting second. If Villar was hitting, I'd love him and Brinson one/two but that's not happening yet. Broxton shouldn't be anywhere near the top, or in it at all. I agree with you though, without Braun and Shaw, the lineup just isn't the same. We really need them back - no idea when that's happening on either. Haven't heard a peep about Shaw, which is scary given the situation. For the time being, Thames is exactly where he should be. I think when everybody is healthy, I'd rather him bat 5th, behind Shaw, but I'm ok if it's second as well. Thames seems to be trying to do too much with the other guys out and it's lead to some slumps and quite a few strikeouts.