It's tough to put a finger on, other than to pull out the same old boring word about consistency. In everything, really. Take the first inning. We score two against Thompson. Renfroe follows with a grounder steered through the right side vs the shift. Smart. Then Wong walks. We score no more, but forced the guy to throw 26 or 27 pitches. Great start to screwing up their pen for the whole weekend.
In the second inning, we only make him throw 7.
By the last two/three innings we've got McCutchen swinging 2-0 leading off the inning, and then the chases, turning 2-1 counts into 1-2, potential 3-2 counts into chased swings, and so on.
Ashby allowing a potential 4 runs that had nothing to do with batted balls.
The talent to at least reach post-season is there. I mean, MLB has seen to that with the expansion of the playoffs. Whether it's Counsell, the players, hitting coaches, whoever, the consistency isn't.