The biggest problem is that Rickie was too good at AA and AAA. He could have used a few more seasons in the minors, fine tuning his defense and becoming a better hitter. He was a fulltime player by the age of 22. For comparison sake, Brandon Phillips was also a full time player at 22 for the Tribe but put up a Weeks-ish .208/.242/.311 line, and was rightfully sent back down. He played 12 more games in the bigs over the next two years before ultimately running out of options and being traded to the Reds. It was finally his age 25 season (where Weeks is now) that he started to put things together, and had his breakout year last year, at age 26. Chase Utley didnt even sniff the bigs until he was 24, played two partial seasons with the Phils and in his age 26 season he blew up. Dan Uggla didnt break into the bigs until age 26, and I think only because he was Rule 5 guy. Ian Kinsler didnt come into the bigs until age 24, he has been good since he started, but has blown up this year at age 26. I guess what I am getting at here is that I blame Melvin a little bit for rushing Weeks to the big leagues. Aside from a torrid start to this AAA season in 2005 at Nashville, Weeks was just a little above average before that - in a full season at Huntsville the year before he had a .752 OPS, that doesnt scream success at the major league level. If the Brewers had been patient with Rickie we might be seeing his 2nd full year and he might have more success at this level than he is having now. Biggest fear is that he is Adrian Beltre, who was rushed by the Dodgers and figured it out just in time to hit the FA market. It would suck to watch Rickie struggle and then in his 6th year hit .280/.390/.500 and walk with a big contract.