I find it hard to swallow the idea that the team should have traded Hardy after 2008. Escobar wasn't really ready at that point...I believe he was still in AA for most of the 2008 season. Anyway, Doug Melvin did trade Hardy eventually, and got a more than good return in Gomez, so I'm not sure why JJ Hardy is a point of contention anyway. Also, after 2008, the team was coming off it's first playoff apperance in 26 years and the future looked bright. The team should have focused on somehow acquiring another starting pitcher, rather than trying to make Gallardo and Manny Parra carry the load, but that's neither here nor there. re: Prince Fielder, it's obvious Melvin tried to trade him multiple times and wasn't able to work out a deal that made sense. You can argue he was trying to get too much for him, or whatever, but none of us really truly know what was presented in any of those trade talks. I stand by my earlier statements that the team should have gone into rebuild mode after 2012. I don't fault them for trading for Greinke/Marcum and "going for it" in 2011/2012. The timing was right, in my view. Since then, though, this team hasn't seemed to have any real direction. We're just patching holes while Braun, Lucroy, etc. get older and more injury prone.