Yeah, so here's the weird thing. My wife tore her ACL a few months ago. Took her to the ER, and they did some motion tests on it. ER doctor didn't seem to think it was an ACL tear, but maybe a sprain instead or a cartilage tear. Now, an argument could be made that the ER doctor was a moron, but sure enough, the MRI revealed that the ACL was totally torn. Dunno, I'd like to give Caplinger the benefit of a doubt given our experience... but then again, I'm not a doctor. Regardless, my feeling on the matter is that BFnetters (and most human beings) are often looking for someone to _blame_ when something goes wrong, as it that somehow makes us feel better inside. Other than Yo avoiding Reed Johnson, this is one of those things that "just happens".