Car #2 does seem to have a few more options if I'm reading them right (BlueTooth, XM radio, Aluminum running board, etc - although I don't see the aluminum running boards in those pictures, so maybe those options are just all options that were available when the car was new? Why would they list those on a used car?), but not $5,000 worth or extra features. I agree completely with Baldkin. Bring in a printout of the cheaper car to the dealer of car #2 and ask him to explain why there is such a difference in price. If he does not have good answers for you (watch out for the Jedi mind games!) and he's unwilling to meet or beat the price of car #1, then walk. If both Car Fax reports check out, seems like Car #1 is definitely the better value at this point. Edit: By the way, I like the posting for car #1 better also. Why is there no price listed for Car #2? It says internet special: please call. Yeah right.