To be fair, isn't "passable" a bit of an understatement?In the PCL (granted he played in a pretty pitcher-friendly home park; no, I can't find his splits), with a below-average BB/K ratio and OBP, I think "passable" is pretty fair. His OPS was very SLG-driven and he's never flashed close to that much power before. Maybe the power is real, maybe it was the PCL. As others have noted, a 735 OPS in AAA does not translate into a 735 OPS at the major league level. Using minorleaguesplits's MLE calculator, Maldonado's PCL numbers translate into a .223/.272/.357. That's not quite wretched for a MLB catcher, but that barely reaches "passable."