1) Error totals in the minor leagues aren't meaningless, but they aren't exactly chock full of meaning either. For instance, Alcides Escobar is considered to be one of the very best defensive shortstop prospects in baseball, and he'll finish the season with 20+ errors. Saying Gamel "is even worse" than Braun based on minor league error totals is not a substantive argument. 2) I've seen many people erroneously correlate Braun's error totals in Milwaukee last year with his suckitude on defense. Braun's biggest problem, by far and away, was his range at third base, not his throwing arm. Braun has a good arm and I too think that over time he would have started to make good throws. However, his range was so bad that I doubt he ever would have been able to get to enough balls to make him adequate at third base. Herein lies the difference between Braun and Gamel IMO. From what I've seen and read, Gamel's problem is not range so much as correctly gloving, transferring and throwing the balls he gets to. He does well with this occasionally, and at other times the yips get into his head. If Gamel can get his footwork down and his confidence up, he has the range and arm to play third base in the major leagues. Braun had the arm, but he had terrible range. And before someone brings it up, this is not a question re: athleticism between Gamel and Braun - they're both athletic freaks. It's just for whatever reason, Braun didn't react quickly enough to balls at third base (he's said it was a comfort issue). For Gamel, it's not reaction so much as what he does after he reacts. To that end, I think Gamel is more "fixable" than Braun ever was and given enough time in the minor leagues, Gamel will be a decent, albeit likely not stellar, defensive third baseman. I also agree that the Brewers will keep him in the minors to work on defense for as long as they can hold back his bat. This could be through 2009, or even longer.