try taking it to Guest relations during this series and just explain the problem Unfortunately, I live west of Madison, so I won't be making another trip in to this series. I guess I hadn't thought to check the bat's ability to fit, I had just made sure everything was in order (like not in pieces). On one, there is a hole under Paulie's right thumb, which allows the bat to fit better (and stay in place). Yeah, one of my two will stay in place, though some of the green/tan (sorry, colorblind) paint from the bottom of the bat still shows, but it stays in place. The other one has the opening half-closed with paint and the bat won't even rest there. I suppose I could try calling guest relations and see what happens.... not sure what the outcome will be, though. I figure I'll try to bore out the hole.