Uhhh...Broxton has put up around an .800 OPS and has among the best range among CFs in baseball. It's kind of hilarious that you would make the 'you do have to have competent people to play the other spots' argument when Broxton has been easily better than Villar this season. Villar has literally been the best hitter for a month, they're trying to ride the hot hand and he's lefty vs a RHP. I don't get how this is so hard to grasp why they've been trying it. They knew the risk, they're not stupid. It was a gamble, they knew, it lost tonight. Just because they knew the risk doesn't mean it wasn't stupid. We understand why they have been trying it, you don't need to keep explaining it and explaining why you can't understand why people can't grasp it, we grasp it. People have said repeatedly, just play him at his natural position, does Sogard really need the start? You're underestimating the importance of defense. If your entire strategy to work a guy into the game is based on the premise of, 'hopefully nothing gets hit his way unless it's routine', that's a bad strategy. Should we try working him in at catcher too?