I'd rather have Hughes who has at least been good the last 2 months other than one total crapfest outing. Barnes seems like a disaster waiting to happen every outing. Hader is a great late inning option too if Counsell ever actually learns to trust him, but that's obviously not an option today. I'd have Barnes no better than 5th on the reliever hierarchy at the moment. Knebel, Swarzak, Hader, Hughes, Barnes.