Because losing that big of an asset for nothing at all is devastating to the near future after he does leave, particularly for a small market team. So we should trade him now for another team's version of Lewis Brinson, Monte Harrison, Isan Diaz and Jordan Yamamoto? What the hell is even the point of acquiring anyone when, if we dont compete for a world series immediately and at every moment of every season we all want to trade our All Stars and rebuild. Goodness, as I said before if you can compete go ahead and put some talent around him and try to make a run in the next 3+ years then by all means do it. That's fine and good and I'm all for that. All I was saying is trading him eventually is better than losing him for zip if you're in a position after 2020 or so where you're not going to compete anyway and you're hovering around .500 in '19 and '20. I certainly wasn't suggesting putting Yelich on the block now or even in the offseason. And FWIW Yelich is worth way more than when we acquired him, so the Brinson+ trade is not a great comparison, especially being able to evaluate that one with some hindsight. In the scheme of what Yelich is really worth it's essentially nothing. In today's value terms it would be like trading Yelich for Alex Claudio.