While I can agree with you carolinatommy that scouting can seem archaic, but really everything a scout does is intuitive. Two people can look at one player and assess his arm, speed, power, etc differently while both seeing the same thing. You can watch a pitcher throw and both have different readings on the gun. So that is why a good scout is important. After watching thousands of players you can just see the differences from one player to the next and realize the gamer. You can recall seeing Ben Sheets throw in college and see a similar fastball in Joe Schmoe who is pitching at a HS in Montana. It's imperfect, but so is almost everything a human being does. I like scouting and finding of gems. If scouting was perfect then the best player would get drafted in slot 1, second best in slot 2, etc. You'd have not busts and no sleepers and it would be boring.