I still would want my #1 in an elimination game. Does no use in game 5 if you don’t win game #4. Also, CC Sabathia is rolling in his grave (I know he’s alive) at this short rest talk… If CC were alive he would have taken over in the 5th inning, threw a shutout the rest of the way, and then started game 4 to close the series out. Maybe I have a different memory but I seem to recall CC throwing for us on short rest and then getting lit up in a playoff game that was over before it started?