This is a great thread. I share many of the same frustrations with this franchise's inability to take things to the next level. Even when they made the playoffs in 2008, the team still felt like a mess to some degree. I agree with the idea of building around young pitching. I have serious envy of the Marlins because they have no fan support and yet still manage to build strong starting rotations year after year. It feels like those kind of teams have continually figured out something that we haven't. This is what drives me nuts about Doug Melvin. It's like he can't figure out what the special magic ingredients are. I think he can look at individual parts but doesn't have as much sense as to how they will blend together I really think a veteran right-handed power pitcher is needed to anchor any staff that has hopes of contending on a regular basis. When was the last time we had someone like a John Smoltz or Tim Hudson (in their prime)? I am also sick of the soft-tossing types who rely on command and movement. I am fine with Randy Wolf, but guys like Suppan, Davis, and maybe even Bush just aren't going to get you to that next level. Does any opposing team fear or dread facing them? I don't think so. Also, I would gladly dump the whole Gerut / Hart / Edmonds situation for one solid productive corner outfielder who can play everyday and make an impact. I like Edmonds as a 4th outfielder, but I would love to have a real everyday starter. I think Gerut gets better the more he plays, but I don't have a good feel for what his upside is. Long-term, we need someone totally new in rightfield. I also want to see the Brewers be more aggressive with acquiring players in salary dumps. I keep thinking about how the Cardinals went out traded a bunch of nobodies to get impact guys like Edgar Renterrria, Scott Rolen, Jim Edmonds, Chris Carpenter, Adam Wainwright, Mark McGwire, Matt Holiday, etc. Other than Carlos Lee, I don't recall too many impact moves by the Brewers to add offense either.