I don't understand the opinion that a home run ball should ever be just simply returned to the batter who hit it. Once it makes the seats and ends up in a fan's hands, to me that just seems like the end of the story. Done deal. Transaction complete. I don't agree with this. The ball is clearly property of the home team. In the NBA, if the ball goes into the crowd -- it comes back out. If a MLB player loses his hat in the crowd going after a foul ball, it is not lost. Your ticket allows you to watch the game, and I think that is pretty much it. MLB allows a lot of fans to keep balls hit out of play, but I certainly don't think they relinquish ownership of an item once it leaves the playing field. One of the lawyer types could certainly correct me if I am off-base. Just curious as to why this thread isn't locked yet, with people making blatant personal attacks on a BF.netter and posting ridiculous speculations without any basis or factual information. This story has been on ESPN, and picked up by the AP -- it is hardly void of factual information. You can't tell me that they couldn't part with a Ramirez bat Hanley needs something to hit with -- The Marlins are on the road, It's not like they brought Ramirez souvenir bats on the road trip with them. I think it is very reasonable for the Marlins to deny a specific bat request when they are on the road. Balls are one thing, bats/gloves/jerseys -- that's a whole other series of considerations. I don't think just being a member of this site precludes you from any discussion or criticism of you actions - especially something like this that is getting a lot of media attention Agreed -- I think that the HY is certainly trying to embrace his "celebrity" status. If you are going to give interviews that get published by the AP and end up on Sportcenter, then you probably need to ensure you are not coming off like a total dipwad and embarrassing your fellow fans. I can't help but think that his story couldn't come at a much worse time for Milwaukee and the Brewers. Yeah, regardless of who said what, I think public opinion is not going to judge Milwaukee well. I am almost certain, not a lot of people are going to sympathize with a "ball hawk". I think the sad thing to me, is that if you read both accounts, it seems like both sides agree that the incident got ugly. It is unfortunate that a night at the ballpark and what should have been an exciting event for both the fan and player turned so sour.