I would assume that Dorn would bat 3rd and Cerrano 4th. That just makes more sense since Cerrano is the big power guy and Dorn is supposed to be a good hitter. So I would think it would go that way and seeing the guys in the dugout without helmets when they should be in the hole is just a production mistake. That being said, I think you are looking way too deep into this, as the movie is filled with production mistakes, like most sports movies are. They just don't take these things into account when making movies. A few examples: At the opening game there is nobody in the stadium. A clock in the scoreboard reveals that it is 10:40am, too early for Major League Baseball games. In the top of the 9th during the one game playoff against the Yankees, the stadium clock reads 10:20 PM as Vaughn is coming in from the bullpen. In the bottom of the 9th right as the Duke comes in from the bullpen, the stadium clock still reads 10:20 PM. In the final playoff game, as Cerrano waits at the plate with Dorn on first in the 7th inning, there is a brief wide shot of the field, and the bases are empty. In the final game against the Yanks, the # 37 player is hitting, Jake Taylor then throws to 1st base to pick off the #37 player. The #37 player appears later in the game, this time being referred to by a different name by Harry Doyle. When Dorn (#24) gets his hit in the 7th inning of the playoff game, the shot of the base runner rounding first base shows his number as #8. When his face is shown again, his number is back to #24. There are members of the New York Yankees wearing numbers 32 and 37. Both of these numbers have long been retired. Harris gives up a double in the top of the 9th inning, which represents the 8th hit of the game for the Yankees. He walks the next hitter and relieved by Vaughn who throws three straight heaters to end the inning. When the Indians are up in the bottom of the ninth, the scoreboard shows that the Yankees have nine hits when, in fact, they only have eight.