Pessimist? Optimist? Is it OK just to try and answer sports related questions objectively? For this poll, unless you thought the Brewers were a truly horrible team, it wasn't realistic to have expected them to never get over .500 again during ANY point of the remainder of the season. Remember, that's a very different question than asking if a team will FINISH over .500. A "true" .500 team (as in actual talent, not current record) that starts the season 16-17 would be hard pressed not to briefly stumble over .500 over the remaining 129 games, wouldn't they? Let's take a quick look. Not sure what the "right" way to calculate this is (in contrast, calculating the odds to finish the season with a certain record is pretty straight forward), so I just simulated it, giving the Brewers exactly the same chance of winning each of their remaining 129 games. I kept lowering the team's "true talent" until it was more likely not to ever go over .500 at any point: http://i27.tinypic.com/20pv5l3.jpg If I'm doing this correctly (as always, I appreciate people keeping me honest) if you thought the Brewers were basically a .500 team going forward, while they would have only a 43% chance of finishing over .500, they would have a 85.5% chance of being over .500 at some point over their remaining 129 games. They would have to be a true 67 win team before it would be more likely that they never get over .500. Either fans were weighing the 6 game losing streak too heavily when trying to estimate the true talent of the team or they didn't realize how easy it is for even a bad team to stumble over .500 at some point is. Probably a little of both.