I'm counting 07, 08 and 09. All years in which the Brewers started hot, then had meltdowns that made making the playoffs questionable (despite remaining "in contention"). And yes, I don't see them getting the lead back this year either. The Brewers were 80-56 on the morning of September 1. They, far and away, held the 2nd best record in the NL. Yes, they collapsed for three weeks, but you're failing to recognize the way they came through in the clutch during the final 7 games. Teams go on hot and cold streaks. Keep in mind that the 2006 St. Louis Cardinals lost 10 or 11 games in a row in late September -- I think that's true, although I can't say for certain. Contenders have "meltdowns" all the time -- that's part of the game. Plus, in 2007, the Cubs were playing like the best team in baseball for 2-3 months -- they were on quite the hot stretch from early June through August. Edit: And, props to Crew07. Well said.