Not only this but Shaw is slow. Like turtle slow. There's a fairly decent chance that he doesn't even beat some runners to 2B much less catch the ball with a runner coming at him and pivoting for a throw to 1st. And for guys like Billy Hamilton? Every plate appearance I would have would be trying to bunt it past the pitcher. Either Shaw has to field it and it's going to take him a while to get there or whoever is playing 1st is going to have to field it and Shaw will have to get over to cover 1st, which he isn't going to be able to do fast enough. There is just no way anyone can look at Shaw, his body type, watching how fast he is when he's running the bases and think playing him in the middle infield is a good idea. I'm not going to say it's the worst idea in the world because a manager could theoretically make Mike Trout a 5th outfielder or something but unless there's athleticism that I have never seen, this is one of the dumber things I've seen a team try to do.