Nobody is including DL time. He was up for 58 games, he started 23 of those games at third base and also 6 at DH, though being a DH didn't really help him. So he started only 50% of the time in his first callup. He was then called up again on September 8th and collected 15 at bats in 25 games, which made the callup then pretty pointless. So Gamel was up for 83 games last year, over half the season and got 128 at bats. I'm sorry, that's complete mismanagement of a rookie and one of the top prospects in the organization. Macha and Melvin are both to blame for that.