Who do we keep?

[Ennder]

You think other team's GMs are fooled by an undeserved All Star appearance?

 

I'm sure guys like Sabean probably are.

[jhpc12]

You think other team's GMs are fooled by an undeserved All Star appearance?

Are you saying that Corey did not deserve the All-star vote. Of the Five on the list his numbers matched up pretty evenly with all of them.

[trwi7]

Are you saying that Corey did not deserve the All-star vote. Of the Five on the list his numbers matched up pretty evenly with all of them.

Pretty much. And Burrell and Wright are much better players.

[logan82]

jhpc12 wrote:

Are you saying that Corey did not deserve the All-star vote. Of the Five on the list his numbers matched up pretty evenly with all of them.

No they didn't. Burrell was leading all outfielders in OPS at that point of the season and had much better stats than Hart. It wasn't even close.

 

Hart .289/.327/.504/.831

Burrell .275/.404/.575/.979

[trwi7]

Wright .282/.380/.499/.879
Lee .302/.351/.547/.899
Rowand .291/.359/.445/.804

So you could make a case that Burrell, Wright and Lee should all have been ahead of Hart.