Yeah, FIB4, I'm trying to think of a good 'starter' craft brew... Honestly New Glarus's Spotted Cow comes to mind. Has a little bit of sweetness to it, kind of creamy (it's a cream ale), pretty neutral. Adam, do you know whether you'd be looking for a sweeter (aka maltier) brew, or something drier or less sweet (like the excellent Ranger IPA FIB4 mentioned)? Wherever you're located, Adam, try going to a nearby craft brewpub. They usually do sampler trays of most or all the beers they brew. Are you in Milwaukee? There are several good choices there. Heck, if you explained that you're just starting to explore beer, I'd bet any good bartender would let you sample just about anything he/she had on tap, brewpub or not. Since beer is such a matter of personal taste, you really have to just dive in & try lots of different kinds. Even though this thread is a bit of a monster at this point, there have been a lot of good discussions about specific brews in here. Beeradvocate is a pretty cool resource; membership to the site is completely free. Here's the Spotted Cow page. Honestly most of the reviews using technical terminologies are way over my head, but you can get a pretty good idea of whether or not a beer is worth trying based on the letter grades. Anything in the B range or better is usually pretty good.