His big league stats this year are Dave Bush-esque -- and it's mid-June. And he's a rookie, and he pitches in the AL East. And his stuff blows Bush's out of the water. TheCrew07 did a pretty nice job breaking down Davis's performance so far, and even though you cite mid-June as an acceptable sample size, the reality is he's only made 13 starts this season, and 19 in his MLB career. He was Baseball America's #17 overall prospect heading into '08, & #32 heading into '09. This is precisely the kind of pitcher Melvin should be looking to get for Fielder. Since when is it atypical for guys drafted out of H.S. to play 6 MiLB seasons? 1. I didn't mean to suggest (post #132 in this thread) that the Brewers would get Price for Prince. I'm saying if I'm the GM, I start there knowing I'd likely end up with someone still very good but just not named David Price. You actually said, "You trade a Prince Fielder, you start at Price or Niemann PLUS as the return". I see that you meant in terms of negotiations, but if you start negotiations for Prince asking for David Price+, you get hung up on pronto.