Actually he was above-avg. in each of those seasons, with good seasons in '03, '05, & '06. He was below-avg. in '07, & then horrific in '08. Since 3 years of defensive data is what's required to form a reliable sample, I definitely think '08 should be treated as an outlier. Maybe not '07, since it's not far off his career norms. I agree with monty. I think Edmonds will be fine in limited CF playing time. Sure, he'll be a big dropoff from Gomez, but most outfielders would be. One thing I agree with you about, logan, is that I'd much rather see Gerut in CF.