The core team of young stars that won all those Championships--Jeter, Posada, Bernie, Pettitte, Rivera--were products of Gene Michael and Bob Watson regimes. This is the point to keep in mind. Cashman has finally been granted as much autonomy as he'll ever have in NY - and the best deals to point to are the Sheff trade to Det., and not selling off their young pitching for veterans this offseason. I really don't think you can analyze a guy fairly with all the meddling Steinbrenner has done. However, the Igawa signing has been disastrous - maybe the Yanks needed a contract to take the place of Pavano's (which still has another year left!) as 'least-efficient allocation of dollars' in MLB. I mean, Ca$hman had a deal in place & agreed upon with Vladimir Guerrero, only to have The Boss go out to dinner with Gary Sheffield & negotiate a deal at their table, & ink it that evening. That's a kind of 'drastically different' circumstance to which rluz was referring, methinks. Cashman retained A-Rod, Cano, & their young pitching... meanwhile he's saddled with Giambi/Pavano/Igawa/Mussina/Damon contracts that exemplify the 'old guard' of Steinbrenner veteran idolatry. Not that he hasn't had his own role in the vet. love-ins, but I genuinely don't believe that you can make a fair assessment of Brian Cashman until at least after the 2008 season. I honestly believe that 2007 was his first 'real' season as GM.