It's surprising to me the amount of venom that this thread has generated. I'm shocked, quite frankly. It is very easy to not read them in the first place or like others have said, offer up your own ideas. No offense, but MassHaas puts in an incredible amount of time providing coverage on the Brewers (typically those branches below MLB). My guess is that if he had more time, he'd be weighing in quite a bit more often. The notion that this is elitist is ignoring the valid concern MH brought to light in his original post. It's not elitist to ask people to do just the smallest amount of homework. There are plenty of forums & websites that don't bother with that at all, so it's not like there's a shortage in that regard. If you want to start a thread, shouldn't you do enough work to make sure it's not an 8-post thread? Obviously the count of posts is not directly related to its quality, but you get what I'm saying. Even if it turns out to be a short thread, at least provide something to consider. Imho those who find Mass's assertion offensive/elitist are broadening his brushstrokes. No one is suggesting that we all rate - or that the mods rate - each thread to determine if it sucks or is awesome. Just that if you can stop and take 30 seconds and realize the trade suggestion is really not well-balanced, either don't post it (a post that, intentionally or not, waits for two or three posts away to point out its lack of objectivity), or refine your thought. I personally don't find it offensive to suggest that people should think through an idea. It makes discussion much more stimulating.