Yeah, the reasoning hinged on them signing Sabathia and trying to contend next year (both stretches, admittedly). Apparently there is speculation that SF is CC's first choice since he's from there. A lot of dominoes would have to fall for this to make sense for the Giants. As has been pointed out, however, Sabean is a little goofy. I mean, how much sense did the Rowand signing make knowing that the team would be pretty terrible for a minimum of two years (likely Rowand's last 2 effective seasons), not to mention the Zito abomination.