What about his OBP/SLG though? 119 wRC+ career vs lefties, 115 wRC+ career vs righties. Maybe not very good, but 15 to 20 percent above average across the board. I'm not denying that he wouldnt be an upgrade, all i can think of when i hear his name is a young Mark Reynolds. Reynolds was never the OBP guy Gallo is. Nor the baserunner, nor the fielder. Edit: I'm comparing young Reynolds to current Gallo, not their whole careers.