#1 flaw in replay is that it doesn't work. #1a flaw is that it ruins the enjoyment of the game. We've all seen calls that are reviewed, and they still get it wrong. Not just on rare occasion, but pretty consistently. Why? They hang their hat on the old "need overwhelming evidence to overturn" or whatever they call it. What really bother me though is that it sucks the fun out of the game. That instant reaction you get after a great play is now muted. Braun guns someone at 3rd...wait...don't get excited...wait for the review. I hate that. I really hate it. With 162 games, you will have some calls go against you, some for you. It evens out. Baseball is played by humans. Players make mistakes. Managers make mistakes. And yes, umpires make mistakes. Accept that and move on. For those of you (most of you) who like replay, let me ask you this. Why does it matter to get a close play at 1B right, when balls/strikes have a much bigger impact on the game every night, yet that can't be reviewed. This selective approach to what can/ can't be reviewed doesn't solve anything. It just slows down the game, dulls the excitement, and really isn't fair since the reviews are still subjective- just like the call on the field. I could live with limited replay in the playoffs. Would be horrible for the game for a team to lose the WS on a blown HR call, play at the plate, etc. But that's it.