I had to make somewhat of a similar choice. I was deciding between Austin and Albuquerque. At first it seemed like a no brainer and we were moving to Austin. After some careful thought and deliberation we couldn't decided and ended up flipping a coin and moving to ABQ. I couldn't be happier, although I am sure I would have loved Austin as well. Since I don't know much about Boise I will stick to what I know about Austin Pros: Awesome social scene. Tons of bars, live music and things to do Warm Weather. Its beautiful there. A little on the muggy side but not as bad as a place like Houston or Florida. The other big 3 in Texas are all very close. Going to San Antonio, Houston or Dallas is no more than a weekend trip away.Great Vibe. The city has an amazing energy to it. Job market and economy in general in TX has been better than most places during the economy ConsExpensive housing. At least to live where the action is (Downtown, Congress, Hyde Park etc)Traffic is awful. The city has grown too fast for its infrastructure.There is a decent amount of things to do outdoors wise, but the terrain isn't nearly as "interesting" as you would find in the West. In the end we opted for something a little slower paced, with awesome access to the outdoors and a little cheaper. One major thing that led us to ABQ was the climate. It is the best all year climate in the country. We get four seasons but none of them are that extreme and there is no humidity. That is the one thing that led me away from Austin, but we were in the position were we couldn't really choose a bad city. PS: I'm 26