Still not seeing a problem with Edmonds in CF so far this year, he might not be great out there but I'm not wincing when the ball is hit to CF either, offensively he is doing fine so far. The question really is whether Edmonds in CF and Hart in RF is better than Edmonds in RF and Gomez in CF or why put Gerut in RF when Edmonds is in CF. Just because you don't cringe when the ball is hit to him doesn't make him the best option. I thought a manager's job was to put his players in the best position to succeed. In my opinion Edmonds is probably the 3rd best option defensively in CF. I would go with Gerut in CF over Edmonds but could see Edmonds offsetting the difference with his bat. When they are both out there, I see no reason for Edmonds to be in CF.