So, here is how things turned out for the 3 keeper teams I listed above before the season started. Situation #1: Final Standings: 1st place Ended up keeping Votto, Correa, Kershaw, Sale and deGrom. Correa and deGrom were both major disappointments, but I was able to draft well enough that I absorbed the loss and finished almost 500 points ahead of the 2nd place team. Situation #2: Final Stangings: 1st place Ended up keeping Bumgarner, Kershaw, Sale, Scherzer, Syndergaard, and deGrom. All starting pitchers. deGrom disappointed, but with those other 5 anchoring my starting rotation, I was able to overcome his poor season. Mistake: Letting Altuve go back into the draft pool. Probably should have kept him over deGrom, but hindsight is always 20/20. Situation #3 Final Standings: 3rd place Ended up keeping Abreu, Strasburg, Sale, Felix, Syndergaard, deGrom, Kimbrel Many disappointments on this squad, starting with Abreu, deGrom, Felix and Kimbrel. All underperformed, and cost me another title. I finished only 75 points out of 1st place, so had any of those pitchers lived up to my expectations, I could have easily won that lague too. Mistake: Letting Mookie Betts go back into the draft pool. Should have kept him and cut Kimbrel loose. *NONE of my leagues are playoff leagues. We go straight up "most points during the course of the regular season, WINS!*