Give up the NL HR leader for nothing!? Payroll isn't a critical issue, and even if it were, 8M for a 40+ hr guy is a tradable contract. Non-tendering Nieuwenhuis makes sense. He's not that good, and not trade bait. But just looking at the homeruns in a vacuum is a poor way of looking at things. Billy Hamilton was 2nd in the NL in steals, and the NL stolen base leader a year ago, and is probably worth a shade over league minimum. Chris Carter is just a shade above a replacement player because of his terrible batting average, and his extremely bad defense. That being said the issue is "do the Brewers have a readily available replacement?" No, they don't, so he'll probably get tendered anyways. But for all that, all of Carter's homeruns don't even offeset his positional adjustment, bad defense, and mediocre OBP.