I think the key in all of this was "compared to Khris Davis" Many have been praising his defense here with no comparison to Khris Davis. Interesting. Khris Davis' defense was pretty terribad. I think a lot (not all) of the talk of Santana's defense was that he would be an upgrade from Davis in that department. IIRC, Davis had the worst ranked throwing arm of all outfielders in MLB last year. I think his release velocity was less than like 77 mph. Obviously defense is more than just throwing arm, but that's just absolutely atrocious. That being said, I think Santana will probably be around 'Average" in the outfield (which again, will be an upgrade from Davis). Davis was -1.1 DWAR last year, -.2 the year before, and -.4 the year before that (partial year), so whatever the "eye test" says, the numbers say he's just not good out there.