Ok, several points here. I'm not a Mike Bay fanboy. He is what he is, a Summer Blockbuster director. He knows it, we know it, there's no reason to be surprised when we get a movie from him that's a little light on character development, but heavy on action. When I go to a movie, I pay to be entertained. With that in mind, I go with an extremely open mind, with the whole idea that I'm going to kick back and relax for a few hours, and not be overly critical about what I'm about to see. There's a legion of Transformer fans, as well as self appointed movie critics (not to say that's a bad thing) who were going to hate this movie, no matter what. Their minds were made up before they went in. Point in case, I am not at all a fan of Pixar, but we went to Ratatoille this weekend, and I decided to watch it instead of hating it before I actually saw it, and enjoyed it. Ok, that doesn't mean Transformers was a good movie (by certain standards), I guess it just means that I can enjoy just about any movie for what it is, instead of disliking it for what it isn't. Was Jon Voight's character overly cheesy, over-acted, and poorly written? Sure. After sitting back and thinking about it, I have a hard time deciding if I was supposed to take him serious, or if he was the "comic relief guy who's supposed to be in charge". Jon Turturro was really out of place in this movie, and didn't do a good job with what (little) was given to him to work with. As for the action/combat scenes, I guess the "herky jerky can't tell what's going on or tell who's who" doesn't bother me, because I think combat, by it's very nature, is extremely chaotic. Sure, in the context of the movie, it's nice to know as a viewer what's going on, but to be honest, I did not have a hard time picking out "who's who" during the action scenes in this film. There's faults with any film, some (way) more than others. Every viewer has different tastes. I know some people like to say that for certain movies you have to "turn off your brain" to be able to enjoy it, but I don't think that's really accurate. Like I said before, when I pay to see a movie, I try to really enjoy it for what it is, not for what it fails to be.