If the Brewers didn't offer Sheets arby you'd think that Sheets must be seriously injured right? Well the Dodgers didn't pick up Penny's option despite having to pay $2m to buy him out on an $8m contract. A healthy Penny at a marginal cost of $6m is a great deal. The fact the Dodgers said no, if even to just trade Penny, means that Penny's health is highly questionable.