Eric Byrnes took a discount to get $10 million a year over 4 years. Byrnes over 4 vs Dye over two is a toss up. My problem with the Dye signing is that the White Sox really aren't able to compete over the next two years. But to pretend that there would some cheap solution out there that can give you an 800 OPS without a large injury risk is just not true. Sure they coudl bring in Milton Bradley at $6 million, but there is a reason for that.