I'm not sure you need one hand to count the number of people here who want Jackson due to his W-L record. Congrats endaround. I had set the over/under for someone deriding my bringing up a W/L record at 2 hours. Remind me again. How many starting pitchers with an under .500 record are in Cooperstown? Kidding aside, of course it's not all that significant, but it's not a small sample and how do you explain away his 4.40 career ERA? His stats say he's a number 3 starter at best and more like a 4. It was also not the main point of my post, which was that his frequent appearences in the postseason have led to the perception that he is better than his actual numbers say he is. The same way I can explain RA Dickey having a career ERA of 4 despite winning the Cy Young. Jackson was a bad pitcher before 2009. But what he did 7 years ago isn't that relevant to what he would do next year. He is his xFIP for the last three years: 3.71, 3.73, 3.79. Those aren't #1 numbers, but those are solid #2 starter numbers.