Melvin's major failings: 1. Believing that Ned Yost is/was a capable major league manager. This, I think, is the most damning evidence that Melvin has some serious flaws as a general manager. No, I'm not talking about Yost's ability to 'get the most out of his players,' or his ability to stave off a September collapse. Yost had little to do with these things, save perhaps for creating a tense atmosphere in the clubhouse. What I'm talking about is Yost's ineptitude with regards to the fundamental strategy of the game. Throughout his tenure, Yost showed a basic inability to effectively manage the bullpen (not understanding left-handed/right-handed splits, not understanding which relievers work optimally upon a day's rest - remember Turnbow before his implosion, and Matt Wise). He also displayed a stubborn dislike of platoons, an inability to pinch-hit for his catcher or other offensively challenged position players, a tendency to implement and then abandon certain schemes - the pitcher batting eighth, and the whole home/road pitching platoon debacle. The list goes on. The fact that Melvin condoned, nay, supported this manager, makes me question Melvin's plans for the future of this franchise. 2. Underestimating the impact of defense. There are some players, perhaps, who should be given leeway in discussions upon their defensive deficiencies. These players should be solidly above-average offensively at that position. Rickie Weeks does not fit this definition. Neither did Johnny Estrada. And Ryan Braun was simply unable to play his position, a fact that should have been recognized in the minor leagues so that we didn't have to rely upon a historically bad defensive performance at third-base as we participated in a pennant race. Yes, management should stay loyal to a defensively-challenged, young ballplayer, but only if that individual has the ceiling of at least mediocrity at their position. Melvin believed that Braun and Weeks could be mediocre at their positions. He was wrong. Unfortunately, he seems to be repeating this experiment with Mat Gamel. Granted, Gamel may prove me wrong, but when everyone outside the organization, collectively, decries a person's defense, it paints a pretty damning picture. At this point, I will say that Melvin is refusing to learn from past history. 3. Underestimating the impact of on-base-percentage. Or perhaps it is not underestimating, but rather a failure to acquire individuals with this skillset. But this is a major, major failing. The Brewers started the season with only one individual (one!) who would go on to have an OBP higher than .350, and that is Prince Fielder at .372. Durham has a .370 OBP but he was acquired later on, as we all know. Second in OBP is J.J. Hardy, at .345, third is Craig Counsell, at .343. Now, in some respects, it is hard to blame Melvin because almost all the Brewers regulars have seen large drops in their OBP from last year. So I will not blame him so much for this one, but hope that he will look to upgrade this facet of the club in the future. 4. Contracts. Suppan, Hall, Turnbow, Gagne. Suppan, Hall, and Turnbow are at least understandable (Suppan being the least understandable of the three). Gagne was just a bad decision considering his collapse in Boston of last year, and also considering that the ten million dollars could have acquired a plethora of functional bullpen arms. Do I want to see Melvin fired? No. But I hope that he's smart enough to learn from his mistakes. I hope that he can adapt his thinking and admit to himself - 'Oh, some of the directions that I am taking this ball club may not be the best way to win. Maybe I should explore other avenues." However, I also wouldn't be disappointed if he was fired, if, and only if, Jack Z. replaces him.