Maybe but it was the last out of the game, Berkman was hobbling, it was a bang bang play, Hall has been amazing defensively lately. All signs point towards hang at 1B as far as I'm concerned. It is distrurbing to me that on a play like this that was so over the top Hall's fault gets blamed on Fielder who at most made the wrong choice between try to stop the terrible throw and hope he could dig out an off line throw that was bounced way in front of the bag. There is no way that the error should be blamed on anyone but Hall. It takes a normal throw for it to be an out, it takes an amazing scoop to make it an out, it takes a split second decision to hop off the bag to block the bad throw.