First of all, those two things are nothing alike. A baseball team, as a whole, controls their W-L destiny much more than a pitcher does. Second, over a full 162 games, the 2005 Brewers outscored their opponents 726-697. And they played in a good division. So, in a way you're right - their talent level wasn't indicative of a .500 team. It was actually closer to a 84-78 team, according to their pythagorean record. The 2005 Brewers had an OPS+ of 104 and an OPS+ against of 106. The 2007 Brewers have an OPS+ of 106 and an OPS+ against of 100. I couldn't find the W3 for the 2005 team but I can almost gaurentee its lower than this year. Our pitching is better(even with the horrible defense) and our offense is better this year than in 2005.