Melvin's worst deal in retrospect was offering KRod Arbitration, which didn't seem like a bad idea at the time, but ended up costing a huge amount of money for mediocre performance. Obviously, the You don't get Grienke to waive his no trade without Marcum, so I will maintain that was a good trade to this day. Given that we were so close to the WS, I still think it was great. I think the JJ deal was a decent one, because you got a valuable and cheap player in Gogo and Hardy was about to become a FA anyway. We got more out of Gogo last year than the twins got from Hardy before he hit FA. His worst trade is easily the Lee and Cruz for Coco and Munch. Coco ended up being great and we had no idea that Cruz would be this great, but Munch was awful.