I think what both of them did has more to do with the trend of the game at the time than what they preferred. Maybe that is what Melvin preferred though, I don't really know. It was also just a pretty different inheritance that each had. Melvin had most of a young core. They drafted Hardy, Hart, Braun, Fielder, Weeks, etc. pretty early on in his time here. By the time most of those guys were MLB players, it made sense to do the big-ticket "over the hump" type of moves that he did. He didn't need to go bargain hunting for offense because he had a roster full of hitters. It is really difficult to bargain hunt FA for playoff pitchers. Not impossible, but difficult. So trading chips away for Sabathia and Greinke does make some sense to me for when he did it. Of course there's Suppan too. Yeah, I think Stearns is a bit more of a pragmatist and better overall. But Doug Melvin deserves a really nice place in Brewers history.